2026 MLB Annual Awards: How MVP, Cy Young, and Rookie of the Year Are VotedGuides · Baseball · Formats & rules

2026 MLB Annual Awards: How MVP, Cy Young, and Rookie of the Year Are Voted

Key points

  • Four major awards voted on by the BBWAA
  • Cy Young and Reliever of the Year awards announced
  • MVP announced: Alvarez, Crow-Armstrong

1The Bottom Line

  • The four traditional major awards are voted on by the Baseball Writers' Association of America (BBWAA): MVP (Most Valuable Player), Cy Young Award, Rookie of the Year (officially named "Jackie Robinson Rookie of the Year"), and Manager of the Year, one for each league (AL and NL); starting in 2026, a fifth award, "Reliever of the Year Award," has been added, see details below. (BBWAA Voting FAQ)
  • 30 ballots for each award in each league: 15 cities per league, 2 writers per city. Voting concludes before the postseason begins and only considers regular-season performance. (BBWAA Voting FAQ)
  • 2026 announcement dates (U.S. dates): Rookie of the Year was announced on 11/9; AL Kevin McGonigle received 28 first-place votes, NL Sal Stewart received 20 first-place votes. Manager of the Year was announced on 11/10: AL Will Venable received 15 first-place votes, NL Pat Murphy received 20 first-place votes. Cy Young Award and Reliever of the Year Award were announced on 11/11: AL Cy Young Cam Schlittler, Reliever of the Year Louis Varland; NL Cy Young Jacob Misiorowski, Reliever of the Year Mason Miller. MVP was announced on 11/12: AL Yordan Alvarez (Astros) with all 30 first-place votes and 420 points, NL Pete Crow-Armstrong (Cubs) with all 30 first-place votes and 420 points, both elected unanimously. For schedule and results, see MLB.com Awards Season Announcement, 2026 MVP Results Page, BBWAA AL MVP, NL MVP, BBWAA AL Cy Young, NL Cy Young, AL Reliever of the Year, and NL Reliever of the Year.
  • Taiwan time: Rookie of the Year was announced on 11/10 (Tue) 08:00; Manager of the Year was announced on 11/11 (Wed) 08:00, AL winner Will Venable, NL winner Pat Murphy; Cy Young Award and Reliever of the Year Award were announced on 11/12 (Thu) 08:00; for Taiwan time and actual results for MVP, refer to the MLB.com Awards Season Announcement.
  • Scoring differs: MVP ballots rank 10 players (14 points for 1st place), Cy Young ballots rank 5 players (7 points), Rookie of the Year is also 5 players starting in 2025 (7 points), and Manager of the Year ranks 3 managers (5 points).
  • Finalists = Top three vote-getters, typically announced about one week before the awards. The 2026 finalists were announced on 11/2 (Mon) at 18:00 ET, which was 11/3 (Tue) 07:00 in Taiwan; see "Finalists" below for details.
  • Taiwanese and Japanese players: All 4 of Shohei Ohtani's MVPs were won unanimously, making him the only player in history with multiple unanimous wins; Chien-Ming Wang finished 2nd in the 2006 AL Cy Young Award voting.

2Who Votes? How Do They Vote?

Voters: 2 Writers per City

BBWAA rules state that 2 writers from each Major League city are recommended by the local chapter chair and approved by the national secretary-treasurer to vote on the awards for the league to which that city belongs. Writers in AL cities vote on AL awards, and writers in NL cities vote on NL awards, resulting in a total of 30 ballots per award per league. (BBWAA Voting FAQ)

A few details:

  • Eligibility: Active members of the BBWAA are eligible regardless of seniority; some honorary members may also vote. This differs from the Hall of Fame, where voters must be active members for 10 consecutive years. (BBWAA Voting FAQ)
  • National writers: Most do vote, typically assigned under the chapter of their place of residence.
  • Some cannot vote: Outlets like the *Los Angeles Times* and *The New York Times* prohibit their writers from voting due to conflict-of-interest policies.
  • A writer can vote on multiple awards: Beat writers covering a team are often asked to vote on two or even three awards, and writers in two-team cities may vote on both leagues simultaneously.
  • Voter ballots are visible: The BBWAA has made full voting results public since 2012; taking 2025 as an example, the official website lists the breakdown of all 30 ballots for each award. Voters include Japanese media writers; for example, Katsushi Nagao of Kyodo News voted on the 2025 NL Rookie of the Year, and Masashi Yamazaki of Tokyo Sports Press voted on the 2025 AL Manager of the Year. (2025 NL Rookie of the Year Voting Breakdown, 2025 AL Manager of the Year Voting Breakdown)

How Many Candidates per Award and How Points Are Tallied

AwardCandidates per BallotPoints per PlaceNotes
MVP10 players14-9-8-7-6-5-4-3-2-1All 10 spots must be filled
Cy Young Award5 players7-4-3-2-1Expanded from 3 to 5 players starting in 2010
Rookie of the Year5 players7-4-3-2-1Starting in 2025; previously 3 players (5-3-1)
Manager of the Year3 managers5-3-1

(For MVP, Cy Young Award, and Manager of the Year, see BBWAA Voting FAQ; for the 5-player Cy Young format, see the 2010 AL Cy Young Award Report; for Rookie of the Year, see the 2025 AL Rookie of the Year Results, compared with the 5-3-1 system in the 2024 AL Rookie of the Year Results.)

Note: The BBWAA Voting FAQ currently still states that Rookie of the Year is 3 candidates, 5-3-1, but the 2025 award report and voting table have changed to 5 candidates, 7-4-3-2-1 (for example, Nick Kurtz took all 30 1st-place votes for 210 points = 30 × 7). This article relies on the latest edition's results page, to be verified again when the 2026 awards are announced.

Scoring Example: In 2025 NL MVP voting, Shohei Ohtani was ranked 1st on all 30 ballots, receiving 30 × 14 = 420 points, with 2nd-place Kyle Schwarber receiving 260 points and 3rd-place Juan Soto receiving 231 points. (MLB.com Ohtani MVP Report, 2025 NL MVP Results)

Regular Season Only

Ballots are submitted before the postseason begins, so World Series and postseason performances do not affect the results. The BBWAA instructions for the MVP ballot also explicitly state: "Only regular-season performance is considered."

32026 Announcement Dates and Taiwan Time

AwardU.S. DateTaiwan Date and Time
Rookie of the Year11/9 (Mon)11/10 (Tue) 08:00, announced
Manager of the Year11/10 (Tue)11/11 (Wed) 08:00, announced: AL Will Venable (15 first-place votes), NL Pat Murphy (20 first-place votes)
Cy Young Award11/11 (Wed)11/12 (Thu) 08:00, announced: AL Cam Schlittler (Yankees), NL Jacob Misiorowski (Brewers)
MVP11/12 (Thu)11/13 (Fri) 08:00, announced: AL Yordan Alvarez (Astros, 30 first-place votes), NL Pete Crow-Armstrong (Cubs, 30 first-place votes)

U.S. dates can be found on MLB.com's 2026 awards season schedule. The estimated times are based on recent practice: the 2025 official MLB Network press release stated that Rookie of the Year was announced on November 10 at 7 p.m. ET, with Manager of the Year, Cy Young Award, and MVP announced at the same time each subsequent evening; in 2023 and 2024, it was 18:00 ET (BBWAA official website awards page); MLB Network has been the exclusive broadcast platform for BBWAA awards since 2012. (MLB Network 2025 Awards Week Press Release)

U.S. Daylight Saving Time ends on November 1, after which Eastern Time is 13 hours behind Taiwan, so 18:00 ET is 07:00 the next day in Taiwan, and 19:00 is 08:00. The 2026 offseason schedule published by MLB.com specifies that all four awards are at 19:00 ET, which corresponds to 08:00 the following day in Taiwan. (MLB.com 2026-27 Offseason Schedule)

During the same week, MLB also hosts its own awards program, MLB Awards (beginning 11/11 at 9 p.m. ET on MLB Network, which was 11/12 (Thu) 10:00 in Taiwan, already aired), announcing the All-MLB Teams, Rivera/Hoffman Reliever of the Year Awards, Hank Aaron Award, Comeback Player of the Year, and others; Taiwan times for other MLB awards: Gold Glove on 11/2 (Mon) 09:30, Silver Slugger finalists on 11/3 (Tue) 03:00, and Silver Slugger winners announced on 11/17; these are a separate set of awards from the four major BBWAA awards and should not be confused. (MLB.com 2026 Awards Season Schedule)

Added in 2026: Reliever of the Year Award

In August 2025, the BBWAA voted to add an AL and NL "Reliever of the Year Award" starting in 2026, making it the fifth award voted on annually by the BBWAA. (ESPN Report)

MLB.com's 2026 awards season schedule lists this award as being announced on MLB Network alongside the Cy Young Award on 11/11, and it has been revealed; the inaugural 2026 BBWAA Reliever of the Year Awards were won by Louis Varland of the Blue Jays in the AL and Mason Miller of the Padres in the NL; see the BBWAA AL Announcement and NL Announcement for details. There is also the Rivera/Hoffman Reliever of the Year Award established in 2014, which was also announced during the MLB Awards show on 11/11 (already aired; official winner list was not found and is omitted here), representing a separate award system.

4Finalists

MLB.com announced the finalists for each 2026 BBWAA award on 11/2 (Mon) ET. The list below follows the official announcement; each award in each league has 3 finalists. (MLB.com 2026 BBWAA Finalists)

AwardFinalists (Player/Manager, Team)
AL Rookie of the YearKevin McGonigle (Tigers), Parker Messick (Guardians), Payton Tolle (Red Sox)
NL Rookie of the YearCarson Benge (Mets), Sal Stewart (Reds), JJ Wetherholt (Cardinals)
AL Manager of the YearKevin Cash (Rays), Chad Tracy (Red Sox), Will Venable (White Sox)
NL Manager of the YearDon Mattingly (Phillies), Pat Murphy (Brewers), Walt Weiss (Braves)
AL Cy Young AwardDylan Cease (Blue Jays), Parker Messick (Guardians), Cam Schlittler (Yankees)
NL Cy Young AwardJacob Misiorowski (Brewers), Chris Sale (Braves), Cristopher Sánchez (Phillies)
AL Reliever of the Year AwardBryan Baker (Rays), Cade Smith (Guardians), Louis Varland (Blue Jays)
NL Reliever of the Year AwardJhoan Duran (Phillies), Trevor Megill (Brewers), Mason Miller (Padres)
AL MVPYordan Alvarez (Astros), Junior Caminero (Rays), Bobby Witt Jr. (Royals)
NL MVPPete Crow-Armstrong (Cubs), Shohei Ohtani (Dodgers), Brice Turang (Brewers)

Regarding Taiwanese and Japanese players, Shohei Ohtani was nominated for NL MVP; no other Taiwanese or Japanese players appeared on the finalists lists this time. Yoshinobu Yamamoto, Shota Imanaga, Seiya Suzuki, or Kodai Senga were also not seen on the nomination lists.

The official latest schedule listed Rookie of the Year on 11/9, Manager of the Year on 11/10, Cy Young Award and Reliever of the Year Award on 11/11, and MVP on 11/12 (already announced). Rookie of the Year was announced at Taiwan time 11/10 (Tue) 08:00; Manager of the Year was also announced at 11/11 (Wed) 08:00, with AL Will Venable earning 15 first-place votes and NL Pat Murphy earning 20 first-place votes. Cy Young Award has been announced: AL Cam Schlittler, NL Jacob Misiorowski; BBWAA Reliever of the Year Award has also been announced: AL Louis Varland, NL Mason Miller. MVP was announced at Taiwan time 11/13 (Fri) 08:00: AL Yordan Alvarez and NL Pete Crow-Armstrong, both unanimously elected with 30 first-place votes (BBWAA AL MVP, NL MVP). (MLB.com 2026 Awards Season Schedule, 2026 MVP Results Page, BBWAA Cy Young and Reliever of the Year Awards)

5What Factors Have Carried Weight in Recent Years?

The BBWAA does not provide a "standard formula" for any award, so the points below are not formal rules, but rather a synthesis of how voters actually made their choices based on the voting breakdowns and reports published for the most recent edition (2025).

MVP: Overall Value, Not Limited to Contenders, Available to Both Pitchers and Designated Hitters

The original text of the official ballot instructions states: "There is no clear-cut definition of what Most Valuable means. It is open to each individual voter's interpretation of who is the most valuable player in each league." The criteria have remained unchanged since the first ballot in 1931:

  1. Actual value of a player to their team, that is, strength of offense and defense.
  2. Number of games played.
  3. General character, disposition, loyalty, and effort.

In addition, an MVP does not need to come from a division winner or playoff team; all players are eligible, including pitchers and designated hitters. (BBWAA Voting FAQ)

What can be seen from the two 2025 votes:

  • AL: Aaron Judge narrowly defeated Cal Raleigh by a 17-to-13 margin in 1st-place votes, the closest MVP vote since Mike Trout beat Alex Bregman in 2019. (BBWAA 2025 AL MVP) Judge's strength lay in overall hitting and WAR: a slash line of .331/.457/.688 led the entire league, and his Baseball-Reference WAR of 9.7 and FanGraphs WAR of 10.1 were also the highest in the majors. Raleigh hit 60 home runs (the 7th player in history to hit 60 HR) and drove in 125 runs while catching over 1,000 innings; his Mariners won their first division title since 2001, while Judge's Yankees were merely a Wild Card team, yet Judge won in the end, showing team record is not the deciding factor. (MLB.com 2025 Finalists)
  • NL: Shohei Ohtani won unanimously. On the hitting side: 55 home runs, 20 stolen bases, 146 runs scored (most in MLB), and a 1.014 OPS that led the NL; on the pitching side: 14 starts, 47 innings, a 2.87 ERA, and 62 strikeouts. Kyle Schwarber hit 56 home runs and recorded 132 RBIs (most in MLB), but only finished 2nd. (MLB.com 2025 Finalists)

Cy Young Award: Run Prevention and Workload, Win Totals Don't Matter

The 2025 results illustrate best that "pitcher wins are not the point":

  • NL winner Paul Skenes posted just a 10-10 record, a 1.97 ERA, and 216 strikeouts, receiving all 30 1st-place votes. His 10 wins tied Jacob deGrom's 10-9 record in 2018 for the fewest wins by a starting pitcher to win the award in a full season. (BBWAA 2025 NL Cy Young, MLB.com 2025 Finalists)
  • AL winner Tarik Skubal logged a 2.21 ERA, 0.89 WHIP, 2.45 FIP, 7.30 strikeout-to-walk ratio, 195 1/3 innings, and 241 strikeouts, earning 198 points; runner-up Garrett Crochet, despite leading MLB in strikeouts (255) and leading the AL in innings pitched (205 1/3) with a 2.59 ERA, received only 132 points. (BBWAA 2025 AL Cy Young, MLB.com 2025 Finalists)
  • An even more extreme historical example is Felix Hernandez in 2010: a 13-12 record, but a league-leading 2.27 ERA and league-leading innings pitched, garnering 21 1st-place votes out of 28 ballots. His 13 wins set the record at the time for the fewest wins by a starting pitcher in a full season, which was later broken by deGrom (10 wins in 2018) and Skenes (10 wins in 2025). (BBWAA 2010 AL Cy Young)

Rookie of the Year: Full-Season Performance Plus Volume, Not Just Potential

First, eligibility: a player must qualify for rookie status, which means that in prior seasons, they accumulated no more than 130 at-bats or 50 innings pitched in Major League Baseball, and spent no more than 45 days on an active MLB roster (time on the injured list excluded). (MLB.com Rookie Eligibility Rules)

2025 results:

  • AL: Nick Kurtz won unanimously. In 117 games, he hit 36 home runs with a 173 OPS+, tying José Abreu in 2014 for the highest by a rookie with at least 400 plate appearances in the modern era (since 1900). Runner-up was teammate Jacob Wilson, who batted .311. (BBWAA 2025 AL Rookie of the Year, MLB.com 2025 Finalists)
  • NL: Drake Baldwin (.274, 19 HR, 80 RBI, .810 OPS, with RBIs leading all NL rookies) earned 183 points, defeating Cade Horton's 139 points. Horton had the best ERA among rookie starting pitchers (2.67) and his 11 wins led all rookie pitchers, but he pitched only 118 innings. (BBWAA 2025 NL Rookie of the Year, MLB.com 2025 Finalists)

Manager of the Year: Team Record Plus "How Far They Exceeded Expectations"

This award considers only the regular season, and each voter names only 3 managers. In 2025, winners in both leagues led their teams to division titles:

  • AL: Stephen Vogt (Guardians, winning for the second straight year) earned 113 points and 17 1st-place votes, topping John Schneider (Blue Jays) with 91 points and 10 1st-place votes. The Guardians once trailed first place by 15.5 games in July before rallying past the Tigers to capture the division title; the Blue Jays went from last place in the AL East in 2024 straight to division champions (worst-to-first). No AL manager appeared on all 30 ballots. (BBWAA 2025 AL Manager of the Year, MLB.com 2025 Finalists)
  • NL: Pat Murphy (Brewers, also winning for the second straight year) captured 27 1st-place votes out of 30 ballots, totaling 141 points. The Brewers went 97-65 in the regular season, the best record in MLB. (BBWAA 2025 NL Manager of the Year, MLB.com 2025 Finalists)

Summary

AwardApparent Priorities in Recent Years (Based on 2025)
MVPOverall contribution (offense and defense plus baserunning, WAR frequently cited); team record is not a barrier; available to both pitchers and designated hitters
Cy Young AwardRun prevention metrics like ERA, WHIP, and FIP, combined with innings pitched; win totals have minimal influence
Rookie of the YearFull-season offensive volume and overall production; eligibility depends on at-bats, innings pitched, and roster time
Manager of the YearRegular-season record, and whether the team mounted an unexpected comeback or turnaround

6Records Related to Taiwanese and Japanese Players

Only records with verified sources are listed.

Shohei Ohtani

  • Rookie of the Year: 2018 AL Rookie of the Year, Angels. (BBWAA 2018 AL Rookie of the Year)
  • 4 MVPs in total, all won unanimously: 2021 and 2023 in the AL, 2024 and 2025 in the NL. He is the 2nd player in history to win 4 MVPs (Barry Bonds leads with 7), the only player to win two in each league, and the only player to win MVP unanimously multiple times. When winning the NL MVP in 2024, he became the first full-time designated hitter in history to win MVP. (BBWAA 2025 NL MVP, MLB.com Ohtani MVP Report)
  • Consecutive MVPs: Three straight years from 2023 to 2025, joining Bonds (2001 to 2004) as the only players in history to win MVP in at least three consecutive years. (MLB.com Ohtani MVP Report)

Japanese Rookie of the Year and MVP Winners

The BBWAA notes that Ohtani was the 4th Japanese-born player to win Rookie of the Year: Hideo Nomo (1995 NL, Dodgers), Kazuhiro Sasaki (2000 AL, Mariners), Ichiro Suzuki (2001 AL, Mariners), and Shohei Ohtani (2018). (BBWAA 2018 AL Rookie of the Year)

Ichiro Suzuki also captured the AL MVP in 2001, listed by the BBWAA as one of the AL right fielders to win MVP. (BBWAA 2025 AL MVP)

Notable Top-Finish Voting Records

  • Hideki Matsui: Finished 2nd in the 2003 AL Rookie of the Year voting (Yankees), losing with 84 points to Angel Berroa of the Royals with 88 points; the 4-point margin was the closest since the 5-3-1 scoring system was implemented in 1980. (BBWAA 2003 AL Rookie of the Year)
  • Yu Darvish: Finished 2nd in both the 2013 AL Cy Young Award and 2020 NL Cy Young Award voting. (BBWAA 2020 NL Cy Young)
  • Yoshinobu Yamamoto: Finished 3rd in the 2025 NL Cy Young Award voting with 72 points, reaching the three-man finalist list. (BBWAA 2025 NL Cy Young, MLB.com 2025 Finalists)

Chien-Ming Wang

In the 2006 AL Cy Young Award voting, Chien-Ming Wang of the Yankees (19-6, 3.63 ERA) received 15 second-place votes and 6 third-place votes for 51 points, finishing 2nd; winner Johan Santana received all 28 first-place votes for a maximum 140 points; 3rd-place Roy Halladay had 48 points. (BBWAA 2006 AL Cy Young)

2026

The 2026 finalists have been announced: Shohei Ohtani was nominated for NL MVP, but NL MVP was won unanimously by Pete Crow-Armstrong (AL went to Yordan Alvarez, announced at 11/13 08:00 Taiwan time, see BBWAA NL MVP); no other Taiwanese or Japanese players appeared on the finalists lists (for finalists, see MLB.com 2026 BBWAA Finalists).

7Frequently Asked Questions

Q: Who exactly are the BBWAA voters?

Two writers from each Major League city, recommended by the local chapter and approved by the national secretary-treasurer, totaling 30 ballots each for the AL and NL. Voters' names and ballot breakdowns are made public by the BBWAA after awards are presented.

Q: Does performing well in the postseason or World Series help?

No. Ballots are submitted before the postseason begins, and BBWAA rules explicitly dictate that only regular-season performance is considered. This year, the Brewers defeated the Rays 4-1 in the World Series to win the title, but on-field postseason performances likewise have no impact on the voting.

Q: Must an MVP come from a winning team?

No. Ballot instructions clearly state that the MVP does not need to come from a division champion or playoff team. The 2025 AL MVP was Aaron Judge of the Wild Card Yankees, defeating division champion Mariners player Cal Raleigh.

Q: Can a pitcher win MVP?

Yes. Ballot instructions explicitly state that both pitchers and designated hitters are eligible. Shohei Ohtani was a two-way player with both hitting and pitching stats in 2025 and won unanimously.

Q: Does a Cy Young winner have to have a high win total?

No. 2025 NL Cy Young winner Paul Skenes had only 10 wins, yet still received all 30 1st-place votes.

Q: How is rookie status determined for Rookie of the Year?

Having accumulated no more than 130 at-bats and 50 innings pitched in MLB, and no more than 45 days on an active roster (excluding time on the injured list).

Q: What does the finalists list mean?

The finalists list consists of the top three vote-getters for each award in each league. Voting concluded well before the postseason; the list merely announces the top three in advance, and other players may have received votes without finishing in the top three.

Q: How can viewers in Taiwan watch?

All four awards are announced live by MLB Network (MLB Network has been the exclusive broadcast platform for BBWAA awards since 2012). Official information on whether there is a broadcast in Taiwan could not be found and is omitted here; once results are out, MLB.com and the BBWAA official website publish them simultaneously, so fans in Taiwan can see them upon waking up in the morning.

To learn about common baseball statistics used during the season, see Understanding Baseball Stats: OPS, ERA, WHIP, WAR; for the World Series schedule and Taiwan times, see the 2026 MLB World Series Watch Guide; to understand how Japanese, Korean, and Taiwanese players move to MLB in the offseason, see MLB Posting System and Free Agency.

8Sources

Last updated: 2026-11-11

Illustrated portrait of A-Ji

About the author

A-Ji

MLB and NPB columnist

Editorial pen name

A-Ji covers MLB, NPB and baseball data across leagues. He considers plate appearances, pitcher usage, fielding position and schedule context together rather than leaning on a single statistic, with a focus on format differences, useful metrics and overseas players followed in Taiwan.

View profile and articles ›

‹ Back to guides · Glossary