2026-27 Premier League New Financial System: Why Are Clubs Deducted Points? Understanding Everything from PSR to SCRGuides · Football · Formats & rules

Key points
- Premier League replaces PSR with SCR starting from 2026-27
- Old PSR system: Three-year loss limit of £105 million
- New SCR system: Spending per season cannot exceed 85% of revenue
1Summary
When Premier League clubs are deducted points, it is usually not because of on-pitch fouls, but because they "spent too much money."
- Old PSR system (Profitability and Sustainability Rules): In use through the 2025-26 season. It evaluates cumulative losses over three years, with a limit of £105 million; exceeding this results in referral to an independent commission and potential point deductions (Sources 1, 2).
- New SCR system (Squad Cost Ratio): Officially implemented starting in 2026-27, with PSR no longer applicable. It evaluates the percentage of revenue spent on players each season, with a baseline of 85% (Sources 3, 4).
- In the 2023-24 season, Everton were initially deducted 10 points, reduced to 6 points on appeal, and then deducted an additional 2 points in a second case, totaling an 8-point deduction; Nottingham Forest were deducted 4 points—all caused by PSR (Sources 5, 6, 7).
- Manchester City case: An independent commission announced on September 29, 2026, that all charges related to financial rules were upheld, with sanctions to be determined in a separate hearing; Manchester City have appealed (Sources 9, 10).
My view is: The new system shifts the question from "how much did you lose?" to "can you sustain your wage bill?", which is closer to the salary cap concept familiar to NBA fans, except using a percentage of revenue rather than a fixed amount. For fans, the most direct impact is that scenarios involving "selling academy players to balance the books" will decrease, though they will not disappear.
2The Old PSR System: A £105 Million Three-Year Loss Cap
The logic of PSR is: Clubs are allowed to lose money, but the aggregate "allowable loss" over three years cannot exceed the threshold (Sources 1, 2):
| Cumulative Three-Year Loss | Premier League Action |
|---|---|
| Up to £15 million | Assesses whether the club can sustain operations through the following year |
| £15 million to £105 million | Must submit financial forecasts for the next two years and evidence of equity funding (not debt/loans) from ownership to cover it |
| Over £105 million | Treated as a breach and referred to an independent commission |
(Source 2; the £105 million cap applies when owners provide equity funding; otherwise, the limit is lower)
When calculating, expenditures on youth academy, women's football, and community development, as well as depreciation on tangible fixed assets (such as stadiums and training grounds), can be deducted, so "allowable loss" is typically smaller than pre-tax loss on financial statements (Source 2). If any seasons during the three-year period were spent in the Championship, the threshold is lowered, which is why Nottingham Forest's threshold was only £61 million (Source 7).
Real-World Cases
| Club | Assessment Period | Breach Amount | Commission Ruling | Final Result |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Everton | Through 2021-22 season | Allowable loss of £124.5 million, exceeding £105 million threshold | Nov 17, 2023: 10-point deduction | Feb 26, 2024: Reduced to 6-point deduction on appeal (Source 5) |
| Everton | Through 2022-23 season | Admitted breach of £16.6 million | April 2024: 2-point deduction | Everton withdrew appeal; 2 points upheld (Source 6) |
| Nottingham Forest | Through 2022-23 season | £61 million threshold; breached by £34.5 million | March 18, 2024: 4-point deduction | Appeal dismissed; 4 points upheld (Sources 7, 8) |
(Amounts in GBP)
As a result, on the 2023-24 Premier League table, Everton were deducted 8 points in a single season, with the Premier League including an explanatory note on the standings (Source 6). Both clubs eventually avoided relegation (Everton finished 15th with 40 points, Forest 17th with 32 points), but without the 8-point deduction, Everton's original 48 points would have placed them 12th (Sources 6, 8).
In addition, for a breach in the three-year assessment period ending with the 2024 financial year, an independent appeal board on April 8, 2026, upheld a 6-point deduction decision against Leicester City (Source 11). These 6 points were applied in the 2025-26 season; Leicester City had already been relegated to the Championship at the time, so the points were deducted from the Championship table (Sources 11, 16).
Chelsea represents a different kind of case: On March 16, 2026, the Premier League announced that Chelsea were fined a total of £10.75 million and handed a transfer ban (with the first-team ban suspended) due to breaches including unreported third-party payments between 2011 and 2018; the Premier League explained that had these payments been reported correctly, they would not have breached PSR, so no points were deducted (Source 12).
3Manchester City Case: What Has Officially Been Announced
This case is commonly referred to externally as the "115 charges." Below is strictly what has been stated in official Premier League announcements:
- September 29, 2026: The Premier League announced that an independent commission found Manchester City in breach across 9 seasons from 2009-10 to 2017-18, with all financial rule-related charges upheld and most charges related to cooperation with investigations upheld. The commission determined that Manchester City entered into "sham contracts" with certain sponsors, with partial sponsorship fees paid on their behalf by their parent company at the time, ADUG, inflating revenue and deflating costs by over £900 million over this period (Source 9).
- Sanctions not yet determined: The Premier League stated that sanctions will be decided by the independent commission at a separate hearing (Source 9).
- October 2, 2026: The Premier League announced that Manchester City lodged an appeal with the Chair of the Judicial Panel, to be heard by an independent Appeal Board; the Appeal Board may dismiss, uphold, or vary the original decision, proceedings remain confidential, and no further statements will be made before the results are announced (Source 10).
As of October 30, 2026, the Premier League's latest official announcement remains the October 2 appeal statement regarding Manchester City, with no announcement of any point deductions, fines, or appeal hearing schedules (Source 10). When interviewed on October 14, the chair of the UK's Independent Football Regulator stated that the appeal is expected to be heard in mid-to-late January 2027; this was a statement by the regulator's chair, not a Premier League announcement (Source 17). Speculations circulating online about "losing dozens of points" or "being relegated" are mere speculation, not official outcomes.
4The New SCR System: Spending Per Season Cannot Exceed 85% of Revenue
Premier League clubs voted to approve the new system at a Shareholders' Meeting in November 2025, running a "shadow trial" (calculated without penalties) during the 2025-26 season, before formal implementation in 2026-27 (Sources 3, 4).
What Is Calculated
| Item | Details |
|---|---|
| Numerator: Squad Cost | Player and head coach wages, agent fees, and transfer fee amortization (including impairments) |
| Denominator: Revenue | Football-related revenue (matchday, commercial, Premier League distributions, cup competition revenue, etc.) + net profit/loss on player sales |
| Excluded | Other coaching staff such as assistant coaches, non-squad employees |
(Source 4)
How Penalties Work
| Ratio | Status | Consequences |
|---|---|---|
| 85% or below | Within Green Line | No penalty |
| 85% to Green Line + available allowance (initially up to 115%) | Using allowance | Allowance is reduced accordingly; "levy" begins only for breaches in the 2027-28 season, with none payable for 2026-27 |
| Exceeding Red Line | Breach | Mandatory 6-point deduction in that season, plus an additional 1-point deduction for every £6.5 million spent above the Red Line |
(Sources 3, 4, 13)
A few details:
- Allowances are multi-year: Each club starts with a 30% allowance. Whichever season exceeds 85%, the excess is deducted from the allowance; compliant seasons allow a replenishment of 10% per year, up to a maximum of 30% (Source 4).
- How the levy is calculated: Overspend amount × percentage points exceeding 85%. The Premier League stipulates that the levy will only be collected starting from breaches in the 2027-28 season; during the first season in 2026-27, falling between 85% and the Red Line only deducts from the allowance, with no levy required (Source 4). As an official Premier League example: at a ratio of 89% and an overspend of £250,000, the levy is £250,000 × 4% = £10,000 (Source 4).
- Mid-season checks: An in-season compliance test takes place on March 1 each year, confirmed with accounts in June, and finalized in October (Source 4). Under the old PSR system, calculations were made only after reviewing three years of accounts, often resulting in point deductions one or two years after a breach; under the new system, it is theoretically visible within the same season.
- Which season the point deduction is applied: Point deductions are applied in the season in which the breach occurs (Source 4).
The same meeting also approved three "Sustainability and Systemic Resilience" (SSR) tests, which examine working capital, liquidity, and shareholder equity; these serve as financial health checks rather than the primary mechanism for point deductions (Sources 3, 4). Another proposal, "top-to-bottom anchoring" (effectively a disguised salary cap), was not approved (Source 3).
5Differences Between the Old and New Systems
| Item | Old System: PSR | New System: SCR |
|---|---|---|
| Focus | Cumulative three-year loss | Squad cost ÷ revenue per season |
| Threshold | £105 million (fixed amount) | 85% of revenue (percentage) |
| Big Clubs vs. Small Clubs | Same amount; relatively more lenient for smaller clubs | Higher revenue allows higher spending |
| Assessment Timing | Annually reviews past three years of accounts | Mid-season review as early as March |
| Penalties | Commission determines point deduction on a case-by-case basis | Formulaic: starting at 6 points, plus 1 point per £6.5M (levy collected starting 2027-28) |
(Sources 2, 4, 13)
The most frequently discussed side effect of the new system is that "clubs with higher revenues are naturally able to spend more." While 85% is identical for all clubs, 85% for Manchester United or Liverpool is an entirely different figure from 85% for a newly promoted club. This is also why some clubs voted against it; Sky Sports reported that the vote passed with 14 votes in favor, precisely reaching the threshold required for approval (Source 13).
6Relationship with UEFA Financial Rules
UEFA also has its own "Financial Sustainability Regulations," and clubs playing in European competitions must comply with both sets of rules (Sources 4, 14):
| Item | UEFA | New Premier League System |
|---|---|---|
| Cost ratio cap | 70% (initially 90% in 2023-24, 80% in 2024-25, and 70% from 2025-26 onwards as a permanent cap) | 85% |
| Profit/loss rules | Acceptable deviation of €60 million over three years; financially sound clubs can add €10 million per period, up to €90 million over three years (Source 18) | Old PSR abolished; evaluates ratio instead |
| Penalties | Fines, squad registration limits for European competitions, etc. | Point deductions; levy collected starting 2027-28 |
(Sources 4, 14)
The Premier League's official explanation positions the new system as "aligning with UEFA's existing SCR" (Source 3). In practice, this means: clubs competing only in the Premier League can spend up to 85%, whereas clubs competing in European competitions must cap it at 70%. For mid-table clubs moving in and out of European competitions each year, the gap between the two thresholds directly affects transfer budgets.
7Why Do Many "Academy Player Sales" Emerge at the End of the Season?
During the PSR era, a curious transfer phenomenon was often seen in late June: two clubs purchasing each other's young academy players at prices significantly higher than external valuations. The reason lies in accounting:
- Purchased players: Transfer fees are amortized over the length of the contract, recognizing only a fraction of the cost each year (amortization).
- Homegrown academy players: Their book value is virtually zero, so the entire sale price is counted as profit in full.
- The financial year for most Premier League clubs ends on June 30, and PSR uses financial statements, so a sale must occur before June 30 to count within that assessment period.
Thus, the true "financial deadline" is June 30, not the end of the summer transfer window in late August. In June 2024, multiple clubs traded young players with each other around this date, which was widely reported by British media (Source 15).
Will this still happen under the new system? The Premier League's official guidance clearly states that net profit or loss on player sales is still counted in the denominator (Sources 3, 4), meaning selling academy players can still raise the spending ceiling. The difference is that the new system conducts checks mid-season in March and evaluates a single-season ratio, meaning June 30 is no longer the sole critical date. My assessment is that "selling academy players to balance the books" will shift from being concentrated in late June to being spread throughout the year, especially around the winter transfer window, though this remains to be seen once the 2026-27 inaugural season is underway (opinion, not an official statement).
8Frequently Asked Questions
Will any clubs still be deducted points due to PSR in 2026-27?
PSR is no longer applicable to new assessments starting in 2026-27 (Source 4). However, breach cases from past assessment periods that are still under review may still be adjudicated later; the breach period for the Manchester City case spans from 2009-10 to 2017-18, and sanctions have yet to be determined (Source 9).
What is the minimum point deduction under the new system?
As long as the Red Line is breached, a fixed deduction starts at 6 points, with an additional 1 point for every £6.5 million overspent (Sources 4, 13). Between the Green Line and the Red Line, no points are deducted—only allowance is consumed, and starting in the 2027-28 season, a levy will also be due.
Does 85% equal a salary cap?
No. A salary cap is a fixed monetary amount, whereas 85% is a proportion of revenue—the higher the revenue, the more can be spent. The "top-to-bottom anchoring" proposal, which was genuinely close to a salary cap, was not passed in November 2025 (Source 3).
Which rules apply to relegated clubs?
Clubs relegated to the Championship become subject to English Football League (EFL) rules, which differ from the Premier League's. Promoted clubs also have a different SSR testing date compared to other clubs (October 31) (Source 4).
How do Premier League standings affect European qualification spots?
See Premier League Relegation and European Qualification; for the differences between the three tiers of European competitions, see Differences Between Champions League, Europa League, and Conference League; for how ties in points are resolved, see League Tiebreakers Explained.
9Sources
- [1] Premier League official: Everton 10-point deduction announcement (including PSR £105m threshold)
- [2] Independent Commission written reasons in Premier League v Nottingham Forest (PSR calculation and £15m/£105m tiers explanation)
- [3] Premier League official statement: New financial rules (2025-11-21)
- [4] Premier League official: New financial system explained (SCR, SSR, levy, timeline)
- [5] Premier League official: Everton point deduction reduced to 6 points on appeal (2024-02-26)
- [6] Premier League official: Everton deducted 2 points in second case: https://www.premierleague.com/en/news/3960088 ; appeal withdrawn
- [7] Premier League official: Nottingham Forest deducted 4 points
- [8] Premier League official: Nottingham Forest appeal board upholds decision
- [9] Premier League official statement: Independent Commission decision on Manchester City (2026-09-29)
- [10] Premier League official statement: Manchester City appeal decision of Independent Commission (2026-10-02)
- [11] Premier League official statement: Appeal decision on Leicester City (2026-04-08)
- [12] Premier League official statement: Sanctions on Chelsea (2026-03-16)
- [13] Sky Sports: Premier League clubs approve SCR (voting tallies, deduction formula)
- [14] UEFA: Explainer on financial sustainability regulations (70% cost ratio, €60m acceptable deviation): https://www.uefa.com/news-media/news/0274-14da0ce4535d-fa5b130ae9b6-1000--explainer-uefa-s-new-financial-sustainability-regulations/ ; UEFA financial sustainability page
- [15] Football365: Pre-June 30, 2024 PSR swap deals (media report)
- [16] beIN SPORTS: Leicester City 6-point deduction appeal dismissed (Championship table)
- [17] Al Jazeera: Regulator chair says Manchester City appeal expected to be heard in January (2026-10-14)
- [18] UEFA Club Licensing and Financial Sustainability Regulations Article 88 (Acceptable deviation)
Last updated: 2026-10-18